#51

The Tully Monster Mystery

The strange monster known only by fossils from northeastern Illinois.

By Eric Betz|Monday, December 19, 2016
DSC-F0217_01
DSC-F0217_01
The strange, 300 million-year-old Tully monster, with its jointed proboscis and dorsal eye bar, is known from fossils found only in northeastern Illinois
Sean McMahon/Yale University

Francis Tully found his fossilized monster in discarded rocks at an Illinois coal pit in 1958. And it’s puzzled scientists ever since. Work at Chicago’s Field Museum eventually revealed the creature, known as the Tully Monster, was a bizarre 300 million-year-old animal that fed through a toothy proboscis. But was it a swimming snail? An arthropod?

DSC-F0217_02
DSC-F0217_02
A Tully Monster fossil found in Illinois.
Paul Mayer/The Field Museum
Scientists finally moved past “problematica” — creatures defying boundaries — in March. Yale graduate student Victoria McCoy and her team cataloged the monster’s features and compared them with modern and ancient animals, finding Tully was a vertebrate and likely lamprey relative. Understanding the relationship between the animals shows the jawless lamprey are themselves “just remnants of a very diverse, ancient clade,” McCoy says.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comment on this article
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
DSC-CV1017web
+