The nationwide distribution of mixed leafy greens makes it far more
likely that any E. coli they harbor will be spread far afield. “When
lettuce was shipped as entire heads, a contaminated head of lettuce was
unlikely to contaminate another head of lettuce,” says James Kaper, a
microbiologist at the University of Maryland School of Medicine in
Baltimore. “But when lettuce is chopped up and washed together, then
contamination from one head of lettuce could be spread much further.”
Although processors triple-wash the leaves in chlorinated water before
bagging, a minute amount of surviving bacteria—just 50 organisms—is
enough to make a person ill.
E. coli O157 can wreak such havoc because it secretes one of the
most potent toxins ever described, second only to that released by
botulism bacteria. Known as shiga, this toxin is harmless to cattle. In
humans, however, it sparks a cascade of symptoms that begin when the
bacterium injects a sort of syringe into the cells of the intestinal
wall. First the bugs secrete a protein that helps them adhere to the
gut epithelium; then they shoot out shiga toxin, which can reach the
bloodstream after destroying intestinal cells. As it circulates, the
toxin can attack the kidneys, invade the brain, and—in the most extreme
cases—bring on multiple organ failure and death. Those who survive may
suffer paralysis, blindness or chronic kidney failure. Antibiotics are
worse than useless; because they break up bacterial cells, they can
trigger the release of yet more toxin.
According to the Centers for Disease Control, E. coli O157 causes an
average of 73,000 cases of infection and 61 deaths in the United States
each year. The number of outbreaks has actually declined since reaching
a peak in 2000. Nevertheless, “it is a worldwide problem,” says
microbiologist John Fairbrother of the University of Montreal, “and the
ideal solution has not been found yet.” Although the number of cases
from contaminated meat may be declining—the result, he says, of factors
like more rigorous sanitary controls in slaughterhouses and thorough
heating of hamburgers by fast-food chains—the bug is spreading farther
in foods that are less likely to be cooked (and therefore sterilized),
such as fruit and lettuce. Infections from other, rarer toxic E. coli
strains, dubbed O26 and O111, are also being diagnosed more often.
The bacteria have a worrisome ability to survive in many different
environments outside the colon, Fairbrother says. Experiments carried
out by Michael Doyle, director of the University of Georgia Center for
Food Safety in Griffin, show that E. coli O157 can survive in the field
for more than 77 days on lettuce, on carrots for at least 175 days, and
on onions for at least 85 days. The question is how a bacterium from a
cow’s gut makes its way onto a carrot. One obvious way is through the
spreading of animal manure or recycled, treated human sewage on produce
fields. “There is no prohibition to using raw manure on crops, so long
as the crops aren’t organic. Not very appealing,” says Caroline Smith
DeWaal, director of food safety at the Center for Science in the Public
Interest in Washington, D.C. “Treated sewage may be used in certain
water systems that then are used for irrigation. Even tertiary
treatment of sewage may not be enough to totally eliminate the hazards
linked to E. coli.” Contaminated runoff from dairies can seep into
adjacent fields—as probably happened in the Taco John lettuce outbreak
of 2006—and in summer, dust from cattle stalls can drift onto nearby
crops. Other animal feces can also carry the bacteria.